Clovis, California (CNN) — The transgender highschool athlete whose participation on this weekend’s California monitor and subject championships prompted President Donald Trump to threaten to take away state funding reached the rostrum in all three of her occasions Saturday.
A.B. Hernandez, a public highschool junior in Southern California, took first place within the excessive bounce and the triple bounce, and completed in second place within the lengthy bounce within the finals.
Following criticism from some in the neighborhood who stated A.B.’s participation prevented lower-ranked opponents from advancing to the championships this weekend, the highschool sports activities governing physique allowed extra cisgender ladies, whose gender identification conforms with their intercourse assigned at start, to compete.
The California Interscholastic Federation additionally stated if a transgender athlete earned medals in an occasion, their rating wouldn’t stop a “organic feminine” from medaling as properly, the Related Press reported. Meaning A.B. shared her prime spot with two co-winners within the excessive bounce and one co-winner within the triple bounce.
As A.B. was warming up for her first subject occasion Saturday, protesters exterior the stadium used a megaphone to yell “no boys in lady sports activities” a number of occasions till the general public tackle announcer interrupted the meet and demanded “respect for the athletes.” The meet resumed shortly after.
She positioned first in lengthy bounce, excessive bounce and triple bounce within the preliminary spherical Friday as a bunch protested her means to compete, holding indicators studying, “Save Women Sports activities” and cheered whereas an airplane with a banner studying, “No Boys in Women’ Sports activities” flew over the stadium.
“I don’t suppose that having a male in feminine competitors is truthful competitors,” one protester advised CNN, who misgendered A.B. whereas saying as an athlete, she ought to compete in her “organic subject.” Most mother and father who got here with their youngsters to the meet, nonetheless, stated they don’t need the difficulty to be politicized and wish the main focus to stay on the competitors.
Dan Usher, who introduced his teen son to compete within the shot put occasions from Woodside Excessive Faculty within the San Francisco Bay Space, stated he hoped the difficulty will be resolved without delay. “They will must determine,” Usher stated. “Everyone needs to concentrate on the wonderful performances. As a substitute, there are some distractions.”
In Washington State, which permits athletes to take part in applications in keeping with their gender identification, one other transgender highschool athlete, additionally gained a monitor and subject title on the state championships this weekend. Verónica Garcia gained first place within the ladies 400 sprint 2A.
In an interview with CNN affiliate KXLY final 12 months, the 17-year-old defined her resolution to compete on the women’ group.
“If I’m gonna begin residing my life as a lady, it will make extra sense to compete on the ladies’s group – but additionally for my very own security, if I remained on the boys group,” Garcia advised the outlet.
New rule permitting extra cisgender ladies solely applies to championships
In California, the state’s Interscholastic Federation introduced a brand new coverage on Tuesday which solely utilized to this weekend’s meet, permitting “organic feminine” scholar athletes who would in any other case have earned a qualifying mark – if not for the participation of trans college students – entry to the finals.
The highest 12 finishers in most occasions in Friday’s preliminary spherical superior to Saturday’s state finals in Clovis however within the three occasions A.B. was a part of, the highest 13 finishers have been allowed to compete.
The identical day, Trump stated on Fact Social, “giant scale” federal funding “will likely be held again, possibly completely, if the Government Order on this material just isn’t adhered to,” referencing his February directive titled, “Maintaining Males Out of Girls’s Sports activities.”
A day after Trump’s announcement, the Justice Division stated it was investigating whether or not California’s Faculty Success and Alternative Act violates the federal Title IX regulation prohibiting discrimination on the premise of intercourse in education schemes or actions receiving federal cash. The California regulation partly prohibits public colleges from blocking transgender college students from collaborating in class sports activities.
The federal company despatched the announcement in letters to the California Legal professional Common and the superintendent of public instruction, in addition to the California Interscholastic Federation and the Jurupa Unified Faculty District, the place A.B. attends highschool.
The varsity district stated it’s required to comply with California regulation and the state federation’s coverage relating to college athletics.
The workplace of Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat who not too long ago has damaged from many progressives’ place on the difficulty and others, stated the governing physique’s pilot rule is “cheap.” Newsom, in a March podcast episode with conservative activist Charlie Kirk, referred to as the difficulty of trans athletes competing in sports activities “deeply unfair.”
With trans athletes’ participation in ladies’ and girls’s sports activities a authorized, political and cultural debate stoked by the political proper, the White Home has tried to use federal cash to get states to align their insurance policies with its ideology.
Protesters declare A.B. has ‘organic benefit’ regardless of scarce analysis
On Friday afternoon, a protester in assist of trans athletes competing was arrested on the intersection in entrance of the stadium the place the meet was going down after assaulting an grownup male who was one of many “Save Women Sports activities” protesters, in accordance with Ty Wooden, public info officer for the Clovis Police Division.
The sufferer was in his automobile leaving the realm when “phrases have been exchanged and the protester on the sidewalk bumped into the road” and began assaulting him, Wooden stated.
“Throughout the disturbance, one in all them used pepper spray in opposition to the opposite. EMS was referred to as,” earlier than the 19-year-old was arrested and booked into Fresno County Jail for felony assault with a lethal weapon, vandalism and obstructing/delaying an officer, Wooden stated.
On the monitor meet, one coach from Redondo Seaside advised CNN affiliate KCAL “it’s not simple” for A.B. to be competing.
The coach stated of CIF’s pilot coverage: “The answer they got here up with is excellent. They’re permitting her to compete however not displacing the opposite athletes. I believe they got here up with resolution for a tough, difficult query. The issue is it’s not going away,” in accordance with the KCAL report.
One protester advised the outlet what CIF is “doing incorrect is permitting boys in ladies’ sports activities. I wish to see the three classes. Allow them to have their very own class… These ladies don’t have a good enjoying subject. They’re going in opposition to a boy,” the lady advised KCAL, including she believes A.B. has a “organic benefit.”
On the core of disagreements over entry is whether or not trans girls have unfair bodily athletic benefits. Few trans athletes have reached elite ranges of sports activities competitors and even fewer have taken house prime prizes, however their restricted success has fueled the rising motion to ban them from collaborating on groups in keeping with their gender identification.
Analysis on trans folks’s athletic efficiency is scarce, and there have been no large-scale scientific research on the subject or on how hormone therapies could have an effect on their efficiency in particular sport classes, equivalent to working or wrestling.
Trans athletes and advocates say trans folks deserve the proper to compete alongside their friends and reap the confirmed social, bodily and psychological advantages of sports activities.
‘I’ve educated so onerous,’ A.B. stated
This weekend’s meet wasn’t the primary time A.B. confronted backlash as she competed.
At one other competitors earlier this month, she was met with heckling and protesters within the crowd as she was accompanied by campus safety guards and deputies from the Orange County Sheriff’s Division, in accordance with Keinan Briggs, who coaches two athletes who positioned decrease than A.B. in final weekend’s competitors.
Whereas many mother and father and group members are upset, Briggs agrees with those that consider A.B. ought to compete as a result of there may be not a selected class for transgender athletes, he stated.
In an interview with Capital & Primary earlier this month, A.B. stated she has the assist of many of the athletes she competes in opposition to: “Women have been simply shocked that folks would really come to try this, and actually bully a toddler.”
“I’ve educated so onerous. I imply, hours of conditioning each day, 5 days per week. Day-after-day since November, three hours after college. After which all of summer time, no summer time break for me,” she advised Capital & Primary. “A number of folks suppose I’m courageous and powerful they usually hope to be like me in the future. I say, don’t simply hope, make it occur.”
“I’m nonetheless a toddler. You’re an grownup, and so that you can act like a toddler reveals how you might be as an individual,” stated A.B., whose household declined to remark for this story when contacted by CNN.
A.B.’s mom Nereyda Hernandez stated this month on Instagram her daughter’s identification “doesn’t give her a bonus; it offers her braveness. It takes immense bravery to point out up, compete, and be seen in a world that usually questions your very proper to exist, not to mention to take part.”
Each A.B. and her mom spoke at a Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified Faculty District board of schooling assembly on April 8. Nereyda Hernandez advised the board A.B. is competing at the highschool stage in ladies’ sports activities in accordance with the regulation however has confronted harassment and stalking.
“We’re presupposed to deal with all youngsters equal, and we’re supposed to guard our youngsters,” the mom stated, including the group doesn’t really feel “unsafe.”
A.B. referenced the Save Women Sports activities group on the assembly, saying: “If you’ll save somebody, it must be the women on my group who all love me and assist me, they usually’ve advised me over and over that they need me on this group.”
The-CNN-Wire™ & © 2025 Cable Information Community, Inc., a Time Warner Firm. All rights reserved.